Engineering Decisions under UncertaintyModule description #51207 / Version 2
- 6 CP
- Portfolio examination
- Graded
- Winter semester
- English
| Module / Version | #51207 / #2 |
|---|---|
| Validity | Since Summer semester 2026 |
| Available language(s) | English, German |
| Credit points | 6 |
| Person responsible for the module | Cominola, Andrea |
| Grading | Graded |
| Exam format | Portfolio examination |
| Language(s) of instruction | English |
Affiliation
| Faculty | Fakultät V |
|---|---|
| Institute | Institut für Strömungsmechanik und Technische Akustik |
| Academic chair | 35312000 FG Smart Water Networks (SWN) |
Contact
| Office | FSD |
|---|---|
| Contact person | Steins, Ella Luisa |
| E-mail address | steins@tu-berlin.de |
| Website | https://www.tu.berlin/en/swn |
Learning outcomes
After successful completion of the course, students will be able to:
1. Characterize and classify sources of uncertainty in critical water infrastructure planning by distinguishing between aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty and constructing structured uncertainty registers for a real-world emergency scenario.
2. Develop internally consistent scenario sets for deep-uncertainty contexts using a structured analytical framework.
3. Apply Monte Carlo simulation to propagate input uncertainties through engineering performance models by selecting appropriate probability distributions, running repeated sampling experiments, and interpreting output distributions in terms of risk-relevant percentiles.
4. Identify the key drivers of output uncertainty using sensitivity analysis methods.
5. Evaluate preparedness strategies under uncertainty from one of three complementary decision-making perspectives - risk-based planning, robust planning, or resilience planning - and defend a structured recommendation acknowledging remaining uncertainties.
6. Collaboratively produce a structured scientific white paper that synthesizes three distinct analytical perspectives on the same emergency planning problem, including a joint comparative discussion of how framing assumptions drive divergent recommendations.
1. Characterize and classify sources of uncertainty in critical water infrastructure planning by distinguishing between aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty and constructing structured uncertainty registers for a real-world emergency scenario.
2. Develop internally consistent scenario sets for deep-uncertainty contexts using a structured analytical framework.
3. Apply Monte Carlo simulation to propagate input uncertainties through engineering performance models by selecting appropriate probability distributions, running repeated sampling experiments, and interpreting output distributions in terms of risk-relevant percentiles.
4. Identify the key drivers of output uncertainty using sensitivity analysis methods.
5. Evaluate preparedness strategies under uncertainty from one of three complementary decision-making perspectives - risk-based planning, robust planning, or resilience planning - and defend a structured recommendation acknowledging remaining uncertainties.
6. Collaboratively produce a structured scientific white paper that synthesizes three distinct analytical perspectives on the same emergency planning problem, including a joint comparative discussion of how framing assumptions drive divergent recommendations.
Content
In this course, students analyze a common emergency drinking water supply planning case study using a shared set of system data and develop preparedness recommendations under uncertainty through a structured, analytically progressive curriculum.
A strong emphasis is placed on uncertainty quantification as a foundation for engineering decision-making under uncertainty. Students are introduced to the complete uncertainty quantification workflow: identifying and classifying uncertain quantities, representing uncertainty through probability distributions and scenarios, propagating uncertainty through models using Monte Carlo simulation, and assessing the relative importance of uncertain inputs through sensitivity analysis. Throughout the course, the emphasis is placed on understanding how uncertainty influences engineering decisions rather than on the mathematical techniques alone.
The course is organized around up to three student groups, each analyzing the same emergency planning problem from a distinct but complementary decision-making perspective: risk-based planning (expected consequences under uncertain hazards and vulnerabilities), robust planning (strategy performance across a wide range of plausible futures), and resilience planning (system recovery under uncertain disturbance and recovery dynamics). Working in parallel with identical case-study information, students explore how different problem framings can lead to different recommendations despite relying on the same underlying evidence. This insight is examined explicitly through a final symposium and structured inter-group discussion.
The course combines concepts and methods from uncertainty analysis, systems thinking, probabilistic modelling, risk assessment, and decision theory. The central learning activity is a collaborative project that culminates in a jointly authored white paper and a public-style symposium.
The course is delivered in two intensive block phases. Each course day combines lectures introducing the relevant concepts and methods with supervised group work in which students directly apply these methods to the shared emergency drinking water supply planning case study. The first block (Days 1-4) focuses on problem framing, uncertainty characterization, scenario development, and uncertainty propagation using Monte Carlo simulation. Following the first block, students work independently in their groups to further develop their analyses, conduct and interpret Monte Carlo simulations, review relevant literature, and prepare a draft of their perspective-specific white paper chapter. Submission of this chapter draft is required before the start of the second block.
The second block (Days 5-7) focuses on sensitivity analysis, evaluation of preparedness strategies under uncertainty, synthesis across the three decision-making perspectives, collaborative completion of the white paper, and preparation for the final symposium. The course concludes with a structured symposium in which the groups present and critically discuss their recommendations, followed by the submission of a jointly authored white paper that synthesizes the different analytical perspectives into a common set of recommendations.
A strong emphasis is placed on uncertainty quantification as a foundation for engineering decision-making under uncertainty. Students are introduced to the complete uncertainty quantification workflow: identifying and classifying uncertain quantities, representing uncertainty through probability distributions and scenarios, propagating uncertainty through models using Monte Carlo simulation, and assessing the relative importance of uncertain inputs through sensitivity analysis. Throughout the course, the emphasis is placed on understanding how uncertainty influences engineering decisions rather than on the mathematical techniques alone.
The course is organized around up to three student groups, each analyzing the same emergency planning problem from a distinct but complementary decision-making perspective: risk-based planning (expected consequences under uncertain hazards and vulnerabilities), robust planning (strategy performance across a wide range of plausible futures), and resilience planning (system recovery under uncertain disturbance and recovery dynamics). Working in parallel with identical case-study information, students explore how different problem framings can lead to different recommendations despite relying on the same underlying evidence. This insight is examined explicitly through a final symposium and structured inter-group discussion.
The course combines concepts and methods from uncertainty analysis, systems thinking, probabilistic modelling, risk assessment, and decision theory. The central learning activity is a collaborative project that culminates in a jointly authored white paper and a public-style symposium.
The course is delivered in two intensive block phases. Each course day combines lectures introducing the relevant concepts and methods with supervised group work in which students directly apply these methods to the shared emergency drinking water supply planning case study. The first block (Days 1-4) focuses on problem framing, uncertainty characterization, scenario development, and uncertainty propagation using Monte Carlo simulation. Following the first block, students work independently in their groups to further develop their analyses, conduct and interpret Monte Carlo simulations, review relevant literature, and prepare a draft of their perspective-specific white paper chapter. Submission of this chapter draft is required before the start of the second block.
The second block (Days 5-7) focuses on sensitivity analysis, evaluation of preparedness strategies under uncertainty, synthesis across the three decision-making perspectives, collaborative completion of the white paper, and preparation for the final symposium. The course concludes with a structured symposium in which the groups present and critically discuss their recommendations, followed by the submission of a jointly authored white paper that synthesizes the different analytical perspectives into a common set of recommendations.
Module components
Compulsory area
The following courses are mandatory for this module:
| Courses | Type | Number | Frequency | Language | Hours per week | Course catalog |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering Decisions under Uncertainty | Integrated course | 51207 | Winter semester | [en] | 4 | WS 2026/27 (1) ISIS |
Courses in the course catalog
Courses created from the teaching units of this module.
Winter semester 2026/27 (1)
Engineering Decisions under Uncertainty (Integrated course) 1
- Engineering Decisions under Uncertainty (Integrierte Veranstaltung) Termingruppe 1 51207
Workload and credit points
Engineering Decisions under Uncertainty (Integrated course)
| Workload description | Multiplier | Hours | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attendance (7 block days) | 7 | 7 h | 49 h |
| Group work | 1 | 50 h | 50 h |
| Presentation preparation | 1 | 15 h | 15 h |
| Pre-/Post processing and reading | 1 | 30 h | 30 h |
| 144 h | |||
Course-independent workload
| Workload description | Multiplier | Hours | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| White paper - writing and revision | 1 | 35 h | 35 h |
| 35 h | |||
The workload of the module adds up to 179 hours. The module therefore comprises 6 credit points.
Description of teaching and learning methods
The module is delivered in two intensive blocks. The first block (Days 1-4) focuses on problem framing, uncertainty characterization, scenario development, and uncertainty propagation. This is followed by a supervised independent project phase during which student groups further develop their analyses and draft substantial portions of the white paper. The second block (Days 5-7) focuses on sensitivity analysis, evaluation of preparedness strategies, synthesis across perspectives, and the final symposium.
The Day 7 symposium functions as the course's primary integrative experience. Each group presents its analytical perspective and recommendations, followed by a structured cross-group debate. The debate is designed to surface the role of framing assumptions in driving divergent conclusions from identical inputs.
The Day 7 symposium functions as the course's primary integrative experience. Each group presents its analytical perspective and recommendations, followed by a structured cross-group debate. The debate is designed to surface the role of framing assumptions in driving divergent conclusions from identical inputs.
Requirements for participation and examination
Desirable prerequisites for participation in the courses:
Desirable prerequisites for participation: Basic probability and statistics (random variables, mean and variance, probability distributions) and basic programming experience (e.g., Python).
Mandatory requirements for the module examination registration:
This module has no examination requirements.
Completion of the module
| Grading | Graded |
|---|---|
| Exam format | Portfolio examination |
| Type of portfolio examination | 100 points in total |
| Language | English |
Test elements
| Name | Points/Weight | Category | Duration/Extent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Symposium presentation and Q&A | 40 | oral | 25 min + 15 min (per group) |
| White paper - individual group chapter | 40 | written | 6-8 pages (per group) |
| White paper - joint chapters | 20 | written | 6-8 pages (for all) |
Exam description
The examination consists of a joint written white paper per group constellation and a final symposium presentation including structured Q&A. The white paper is assessed both on individual group chapters and on the quality of jointly authored synthesis sections. The symposium presentation is assessed on analytical clarity, appropriate treatment of uncertainty, and the ability to respond to critical inter-group questions.
Duration of the module
The following number of semesters is estimated for taking and completing the module: 1 semester(s).
This module can be started in the following semesters: Winter semester.
Maximum number of participants
The maximum capacity of participants is 24.
Registration procedures
Students can register via the ISIS course page or by contacting steins@tu-berlin.de.
Recommended reading, lecture notes
Lecture notes
unavailable
Electronic lecture notes
unavailable
Recommended literature
- Bross, L. & Krause, S (2021) Will There Be Enough Water? A System Dynamics Model to Investigate the Effective Use of Limited Resources for Emergency Water Supply. Systems, 9, 2. DOI: 10.3390/systems9010002
- Kroese, D. P., Taimre, T., & Botev, Z. I. (2011). Handbook of monte carlo methods. John Wiley & Sons.
- Sobol, I. M. (1993). “Sensitivity analysis for nonlinear mathematical models”. In: Math. Model. Comput. Exp 1, pp. 407-414.
- Walker, W. E., Harremoës, P., Rotmans, J., van der Sluijs, J. P., van Asselt, M. B. A., Janssen, P., & Krayer von Krauss, M. P. (2003). Defining Uncertainty: A Conceptual Basis for Uncertainty Management in Model-Based Decision Support. Integrated Assessment, 4(1), 5-17. https://doi.org/10.1076/iaij.4.1.5.16466
Assigned programs
This module is not used in any program.
Miscellaneous
The block course is held over two weeks at the end of the winter semester.